When the Premier League confirmed that Michael Oliver would take charge of the high-voltage Arsenal vs Tottenham North London Derby, the reaction across Arsenal’s fanbase was instant—and explosive.
On social media, in group chats, on fan cams, and across football forums, one emotion echoed louder than the rest:
“Not again.”
To many Arsenal supporters, Michael Oliver is more than just another elite Premier League referee—he’s a figure associated with some of the club’s most controversial, emotional, and unpredictable moments. Whether justified or not, Oliver has built a reputation in North London as the referee who seems to deliver heartbreak at the worst possible time.
No referee is perfect. No referee intentionally targets clubs. And Oliver is widely regarded by many neutrals as one of England’s best.
But football is emotional. Fans remember pain. And Arsenal fans, specifically, remember Michael Oliver’s decisions.
So with the derby approaching—one of the most intense fixtures in world football—let’s break down the 10 moments when Michael Oliver shocked Arsenal… and why supporters are bracing themselves once again.
1. The 2014 FA Cup Final Penalty Shout – “Play On!”
Arsenal fans remember the 2014 FA Cup Final as the moment Mikel Arteta’s leadership and Aaron Ramsey’s extra-time winner sparked the club’s long-awaited trophy revival.
But early in the match, when Arsenal were already trembling after going 2–0 down to Hull City, Michael Oliver stunned everyone.
In the 17th minute, Olivier Giroud went down under a challenge in the box. Arsenal fans screamed for a penalty.
Oliver waved play on.
Replays showed significant contact. Some pundits called it “stonewall.” Oliver didn’t budge.
Had Arsenal lost, the moment would’ve been immortalized in pain. Instead, the comeback masked the controversy—but fans didn’t forget.
2. The Red Card to Mikel Arteta vs Crystal Palace (2013)
In a match Arsenal were controlling comfortably, Arteta—then captain—was sent off after a tangle with Marouane Chamakh.
Even Palace players looked confused.
Arteta was merely shielding the ball. Chamakh initiated the contact. Yet Oliver produced a stunning straight red.
Arsenal clung on to win, but the decision was widely slammed as:
- Harsh
- Unnecessary
- Game-changing
The red card was later appealed… and overturned.
Arsenal fans logged that one into the “Oliver files.”
3. The 2017 Penalty for West Brom – “Handball or Just Bad Luck?”
Few decisions infuriated Arsène Wenger more than this one.
Late in the game, Kieran Gibbs (ex-Arsenal!) hit a cross that struck Calum Chambers’ arm. Chambers was barely a yard away. His arm was by his side. No unnatural movement. No intent.
But Oliver pointed to the spot.
West Brom equalized.
Two points dropped.
Wenger raged in the tunnel, calling it “scandalous.”
The FA later charged Wenger with misconduct—another layer of controversy to an already heated rivalry with Oliver.
4. The 2016 North London Derby – Dier Escapes Two Red Cards
This match still boils Arsenal supporters’ blood.
It was a classic derby—full of chaos, tension, and tempers. But one storyline overshadowed everything:
Eric Dier avoided not one, but TWO clear yellow cards under Oliver’s watch.
- First, he wiped out Giroud from behind.
- Later, he grabbed Alexis Sánchez around the waist, rugby-style.
Oliver… did nothing.
Minutes later, Spurs equalized.
Arsenal fans still insist: “If that had been a red card, we win the derby.”
5. The 2018 League Cup Final – The Agüero Push on Mustafi
Michael Oliver wasn’t VAR that day—VAR didn’t exist in the League Cup—but his on-pitch decision remains infamous.
As a long ball dropped into Arsenal’s defense:
- Sergio Agüero nudged Mustafi from behind
- Mustafi lost balance
- Agüero ran through and scored
70,000 people saw the push. The TV studio saw it. The commentators saw it. Social media exploded.
Oliver waved the goal on.
City went on to win 3–0.
Arsenal felt robbed.
6. The 2020 North London Derby – The Lacazette Decision
Arsenal dominated possession in José Mourinho’s low-block derby but lacked cutting edge. Yet when Lacazette was sandwiched between two Tottenham defenders in the box, Arsenal expected a penalty.
Michael Oliver gave…
A free kick to Spurs. For Lacazette “backing in.”
Replays showed clear contact on Lacazette first.
The commentary team was stunned.
Fans exploded online.
“Only Michael Oliver gives that the other way,” one pundit joked.
7. The Opening Day Red Card to Laurent Koscielny (2013)
Oliver has shown several red cards to Arsenal over the years—but this one still feels excessive.
Against Aston Villa, on the Premier League’s opening weekend:
- Koscielny went into a challenge
- He touched the ball first
- Agbonlahor exaggerated the contact
- Oliver pointed to the spot, then booked Koscielny
- Minutes later, another soft foul saw Koscielny sent off
The match fell apart. Arsenal lost 3–1.
The Emirates booed.
Arsène Wenger publicly questioned the officiating.
That match set the tone for a toxic start to the season.
8. The 2021 Manchester City Debacle – “Everything Went Wrong”
This was one of the most controversial refereeing performances Arsenal fans had seen in years.
In the 2–1 defeat at the Emirates:
Incident 1: The Ødegaard Penalty Not Given
Ødegaard was clipped by Ederson.
Oliver refused to check the pitch-side monitor.
No penalty.
Minutes later…
Incident 2: The Bernardo Silva Penalty Given
Silva dived—or at least heavily exaggerated contact.
Oliver gave it after a VAR monitor check.
Arsenal fans screamed double standard.
Incident 3: Gabriel Sent Off
Gabriel made a soft tactical foul.
Second yellow.
Arsenal down to 10.
The post-match conversation became a firestorm:
- Pundits questioned the inconsistency
- Fans called it robbery
- Even neutrals admitted Arsenal were unlucky
Oliver’s name never left Arsenal Twitter for weeks.
9. The Red Card to Matteo Guendouzi vs Brighton (2020)
This incident wasn’t as explosive as others, but still controversial.
Guendouzi grabbed Neal Maupay after the final whistle during a heated altercation.
However, the confrontation was mutual—both were shoving.
Yet only Guendouzi faced disciplinary action.
Arsenal felt Oliver lost control of the match and allowed Brighton’s time-wasting and physicality to escalate without proper punishment.
When Guendouzi reacted, Arsenal alone paid the price.
10. The 2022 Arsenal vs Newcastle “Non-Penalty” on Gabriel
This match was one of the most frustrating of Arsenal’s 2022–23 season.
Late in the game, in a title race that allowed ZERO margin for error:
A Newcastle defender pulled Gabriel’s shirt in the box with both hands.
Gabriel went down—clearly held.
Michael Oliver waved play on.
VAR stayed silent.
Mikel Arteta went ballistic on the touchline.
Pundits replayed the clip on loop.
Fans were speechless.
The match ended 0–0.
Those two dropped points turned out to be huge in the title race.
Why Arsenal Fans Are Nervous Ahead of the Derby
With all these moments—big decisions, controversial calls, debatable judgments—it’s no surprise Arsenal fans reacted instantly when the Premier League announced:
Michael Oliver will referee Arsenal vs Tottenham.
Here’s why this is causing such anxiety:
1. The Derby Is Too Important to Risk
This isn’t just a football match.
It’s bragging rights.
It’s rivalry.
It’s emotion.
One controversial call can define headlines for weeks.
2. Spurs Benefit Most from Chaotic Matches
Spurs thrive in chaos.
Oliver’s refereeing style—fast decisions, physical tolerance, willingness to let the game flow—often favors the more aggressive side.
3. Arsenal Have a History of Losing Control Under Him
Many of Arsenal’s red cards in Oliver-officiated matches stem from emotional frustration.
A charged derby only amplifies that tension.
4. The Title Race Context
Arsenal are now genuine title contenders.
Every point matters.
Every decision matters even more.
5. Social Media Recirculates the “Oliver Curse”
Every controversial clip has resurfaced:
- NLD mistakes
- Penalties not given
- Reds issued
- Reds ignored
- VAR inconsistencies
- Arsène Wenger’s old rants
The narrative is built.
Whether fair or not… Arsenal fans feel it.
To Be Fair: Michael Oliver Has ALSO Gotten Things Right
For balance—and because facts must take precedence—Oliver has made major correct calls in Arsenal matches too:
- Correctly awarding penalties for Arsenal
- Protecting players like Saka from rough treatment
- Handling tense derbies with authority
- Booking time-wasters early
- Using VAR efficiently on several occasions
He is, without doubt, one of the Premier League’s most respected referees.
But football isn’t just factual.
It’s emotional.
And the emotional history between Arsenal fans and Michael Oliver is… complicated.
The Psychological Side: Does This Affect Arsenal Players?
This is where things get interesting.
Players absolutely remember referees.
They know tendencies.
They remember past experiences.
They adjust behavior based on expectations.
When Arsenal players see Michael Oliver in the dressing room before kick-off, the following often happens:
- Body language shifts
- Players become more cautious
- Defenders hesitate in 50/50s
- Attackers feel they must exaggerate contact
- Midfielders fear tactical fouls
- Leaders spend energy arguing instead of focusing
Even subconsciously, this can affect momentum.
And in a derby—where every tackle, foul, and whistle is magnified—psychological edges matter.
What Arsenal Must Do to Neutralize the “Oliver Effect”
If Mikel Arteta wants to silence the narrative and take control of the derby, Arsenal must:
1. Avoid Emotional Tackles
Spurs feed on emotional chaos.
Oliver punishes emotional fouls quickly.
2. Win Clear, Clean Duels
Minimize any “interpretation” moments.
3. Surround the Referee Less
Constant protesting only builds tension.
Oliver is known for firm responses.
4. Score First
Arsenal often lose control when chasing a match under Oliver.
5. Stay Calm During Spurs’ Usual Dark Arts
Time-wasting.
Tactical fouls.
Psychological pressure.
Arsenal must stay disciplined.
6. Don’t Rely on Penalties
History suggests it won’t come.
Final Thoughts: Will the Story Change This Time?
Michael Oliver isn’t an anti-Arsenal villain.
He isn’t biased.
He isn’t corrupt.
He’s a human referee operating under immense pressure in one of the world’s most emotional fixtures.
But the truth remains:
The history between Michael Oliver and Arsenal is long, heated, dramatic, and unforgettable.
Fans remember incidents.
Players remember emotions.
Managers remember pain.
So the question is:
**Will this North London Derby rewrite the story—
or repeat it?**
Arsenal fans can only hope it’s the former.
Leave a Reply